Status
Not open for further replies.

Robiin

Monolith Newcomer
Member
Joined:
Feb 14, 2018
Messages:
13
Points:
12

6

Years of Mono

LV
0
 
Your Steam Name: JxRobiin
Your SteamID: STEAM_0:1:205650325
Your Character Name: James Alcinia

Which Staff issued the Warning Point: Thegamingshain


Reason for the warning point(s): RDM
Why should the point(s) be removed:
First of all my warning point was given for RDM which I would have to disagree,
I did not going on the server to shoot a random person
for no reason. I was in a situation were I was misinformed by
higher-ups which because of this led me to believe I had KOS on the
on the suspect.

As I described I was told by higher-up combine some of which
being staff, Mentor ec.t you can KOS civilians after confirming
they have a weapon in there inventory, now the argument could be made
that, it wouldn't be right if a civilian is handcuffed to shoot him
if they have a class 3 which I could agree with but since the
half-life event is active with different/new rules I could see why it
would be allowed and also with the Higher-ups telling other combine
this is allowed you can see why a less experience combine like myself
would think it would be allowed and since I have been instructed by
by higher-up's who have a better understanding of rules and the game
in general I am of course going to do what they are recommending
since some of them have a few hundreds levels of experience.
Furthermore why should I be penalized for the spread of misinformation
also if this isn't allowed why has it been happening so often I see
combine doing this countless times without anyone receiving any
backlash this further reinforces how I couldn't of known I was breaking
a rule.
The point could also be argued that I had the right to execute as
Combine are allowed to execute civilians/rebels whether that be the use
of the incinerator, firing squad, The mayors broadcast, public
execution or in my case a simple execution there and then this would of
been just considering the crime he had already committed so would it of
made any sort of difference whether I had to took him to the combine
base to be killed or I had done where I had.
To sum up I do believe that this should of be handle with a
verbal rather than warn which leads me to be banned. I believe it is
unjust and unfair that I was the one do be punished for something that
other combine are doing and misinforming, rather a verbal would of
been more just than a indirect ban.


Time of Occurrence: 22:04pm GMT
Additional members involved/witnessing: @Thegamingshain
Read, understood and followed warning point appeal rules?: Yes
 
Last edited:

shain

Community Manager
Community Manager
Forum Moderator
Member
Joined:
Nov 3, 2019
Messages:
991
Points:
87
Awards
3

5

Years of Mono

LV
1
 
Hello @JxRobiin,

Whether or not that you were misinformed, you still broke a rule, this is on your behalf that you failed to read the rules, you killed someone while in handcuffs because you found a gun in they're inventory. Further more it was RDM since you did have them in your custody.


The only time you are to kill someone or publicly execute someone when you've been told or given the order to by an Over watch.


Also, Could you please specify the staff member who told you this?
 

HockeyExpert30

Monolith Senior
Member
Joined:
Sep 19, 2017
Messages:
338
Points:
52

7

Years of Mono

LV
0
 
Under Review
 

tazdevil335

Monolith Specialist
Member
Joined:
Jun 13, 2018
Messages:
599
Points:
87
Awards
3

6

Years of Mono

LV
1
 
Sorry for the delay,

So although this happened a little while ago, you did indeed not get banned for this situation, you received a WP, however because of your history the WP then lead to your ban which is comprised of all of your previous behavior on the server. In this instance, you did RDM a player, and a correct punishment for this rule violation can be 1 wp, which was given by Shain. However, I would be included to remove the WP and stay with a verbal if you had any proof of another staff member/mentor providing you with false information, shain is still correct that it is up to the players to read the rules, however, if you where misinformed I could understand.

If you have any proof please DM it to me and this report will be accepted.

Denied
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top