Staff Report on gm1003

[mightymelon]

Your Steam Name: MightyMelon
Your Steam ID: STEAM_0:0:86434106
Your Character Name (If Applicable): George Melon


Admin being reported: @gm1003


Reason for Report: False Ban
Time of Occurrence: 5/27/2019 at about 6AMEST, or 10PM.
Evidence to support your claim: Refer to https://monolithservers.com/forums/threads/mightymelons-ban-appeal.19789/.
He banned me for reasons stated in that ban appeal, but when I kept asking him about the fact that he falsely put "LTAS" in my ban reason, even though he never even started a sit, he never responded. He kept avoiding it or acting as if I hadn't said anything. Finally he denied my appeal despite the fact that he clearly made a false ban on at least one of the reasons.
Additional members involved/witnessing: N/A

 

[itz_coffee]

You abused your powers as a security guard, then disconnected shortly after. That’s leaving to avoid a sit, if you were really innocent in your actions (which you weren’t) then you would’ve waited for me to bring you to a sit (but you didn’t).

With no access to your prior rulebreaks or other forms of punishment (and with damning video evidence against you), I decided to ban you.

How am I wrong here?

 

[mightymelon]

You never addressed the LTAS part, and you now admitted you never brought me to a sit. I never abused my powers as a security guard, I knocked out someone who had a weapon equipped in bank (wasn't aware they couldn't unequip), and I wouldn't consider that as abuse... As for LTAS, again, I was on for several minutes after that and then realized it was 6AM my time, and I'd been up the entire night. I was naturally tired and just decided to get off. I don't think that's unreasonable. "if you were really innocent in your actions (which you weren’t) then you would’ve waited for me to bring you to a sit (but you didn’t)." This is just completely bull. I didn't think I did anything wrong, and literally no one ever said anything to me indicating I did anything wrong. I wasn't going to wait around for a sit I wasn't even aware you were planning on bringing me into. You had several minutes after I supposedly abused to try and bring me to a sit, but you never did. I most certainly didn't leave to avoid a sit, and as it's part of my ban reason, and probably the big thing in it, as people constantly FailRP as jobs doing stuff like that without anything other than a verbal (that was my first offense), I don't think I likely would've been banned. So, I definitely think this was a false ban.

 

[itz_coffee]

As for LTAS, again, I was on for several minutes after that and then realized it was 6AM my time, and I'd been up the entire night. I was naturally tired and just decided to get off. I don't think that's unreasonable.

That’s excruciatingly convenient, out of your entire session you decided that the best time to log off was 3 minutes after you finished batonning the victim.

 

[mightymelon]

It's convenient that you decided to wait until after I got off to supposedly try to put me in a sit.

 

[Stuvi]

Report denied. Ban is valid.