Your Steam Name:nooodle
Your Steam ID: https://steamcommunity.com/id/chubbychoob
Your Character Name (Hector Cooper):
Admin being reported( @Scofield)
Reason for Report: Extreme Bias, Excessive Punishment, Denied someone just so he could deny them without actually taking the situation from a neutral perspective
I'm gonna copy and past his reply to my this ban appeal here:
"I understand that you may be upset about the new map change. But that isn't an excuse to disrespect the hard work management and the dev team put into to give the community a fresh, new experience to celebrate our 3 year anniversary.
-How is disrespecting a single map change, even represent the entirety of the work that was put in for it, CHANGE ANYTHING about the work that what was done. Is he required to show respect towards something he doesn't like? I remember when Hitler worked hard on his reich, does this mean people have to respect him?(This is an obvious analogy, please don't take that one too seriously) This is too much of an exaggeration for what happened in reality.
I agree, other staff members may have been more lenient and only give you a warning. However you dealt with the map change in completely the wrong manner in my opinion, and I know first hand the hard work that the staff and dev team volunteered to do in order to produce this new gameplay for the players benefit, and for you to go ahead with your childish and closed minded attitude and say 'you guys are trying to ruin the server' after they tried to improve your personal experience is completely inappropriate and unacceptable in my book.
-If you read this with skepticism, he basically is saying his last statement but he is blowing it up to extreme proportions that don't even represent who @Purple is or what he did. "For you to go ahead with your childish and closed minded attitude and say "you guys are trying to ruin the server" .... is completely unacceptable". Dude, purple is 15 years old. Do you expect a server with an age group of 13+ to have a bunch of intellects that think with an open mind? The brain isn't fully developed until 26. When you put hard work into a free-to-join, unwhitelisted garry's mod server, you aren't going to get perfection with the community. "Sure thats why we ban off the toxic ones"..... I get it, ban off the toxic ones. But what he said is toxic in the eyes of another close minded person. Anyone with a truly open mind would agree that saying ""!help are you guys trying to ruin the server like what am I supposed to do?"" isn't toxic and should have been let go and maybe sent off with a warning. But no, @Scofield decided "THIS IS ABSOLUTELY HORRENDOUS", and gave him a week ban. Why is this behavior tolerated within the staff team? I can guarantee you that @Purple's feelings were hurt because of this WAY MORE than any of the hard-working staff members/dev team that went into the map change. He said he was sorry and didn't mean harm, but Scofield with his power-hungry attitude wanted this man punished as a form of authoritative control. I'll say it again, absolutely NO HARM was done from this comment. It's not like he went around in OOC saying it too, in character, and then proceeded to break rules because of it! A week ban wasn't necessary. Along with this, the way he handled the appeal was very unprofessional. He didn't take it on in a neutral manner what-so-ever. Why is it that hard for you to give another person a chance?
The reason why I put NITRP as one of your ban reasons is due to the fact that you used the !help command to slander and insult members of the community, and not to ask RP related questions like it is designed for. For the reasons displayed above, this ban appeal is going to be DENIED. Additionaly, if you are not happy with my handling of the situation, you may make a staff report on me here."
-Again, this is such an excessive explanation of what really happened. More realistically, purple used the !help command to make a slightly disrespectful comment towards a decision made by the server. The definition of slander is "a false verbal statement that damages one's reputation". So, he misused the word slander there to exaggerate his point. I am not happy with the way he handled this situation, and the staff report is being made. And that reasoning itself is COMPLETELY UNRELATED to "No intent to role-play". It was just another reason he added so he could justify his excessive ban time.
Time of Occurrence:Tuesday, 4/7/20
Evidence to support your claim:
monolithservers.com
Additional members involved/witnessing:
None, I'm sure he didn't even ask other staff members if his decision was fair before responding. He probably thought what he wrote was perfect. More reasons he's not fit to be a staff member.
Read, understood and followed staff report rules?:
Yes
Your Steam ID: https://steamcommunity.com/id/chubbychoob
Your Character Name (Hector Cooper):
Admin being reported( @Scofield)
Reason for Report: Extreme Bias, Excessive Punishment, Denied someone just so he could deny them without actually taking the situation from a neutral perspective
I'm gonna copy and past his reply to my this ban appeal here:
"I understand that you may be upset about the new map change. But that isn't an excuse to disrespect the hard work management and the dev team put into to give the community a fresh, new experience to celebrate our 3 year anniversary.
-How is disrespecting a single map change, even represent the entirety of the work that was put in for it, CHANGE ANYTHING about the work that what was done. Is he required to show respect towards something he doesn't like? I remember when Hitler worked hard on his reich, does this mean people have to respect him?(This is an obvious analogy, please don't take that one too seriously) This is too much of an exaggeration for what happened in reality.
I agree, other staff members may have been more lenient and only give you a warning. However you dealt with the map change in completely the wrong manner in my opinion, and I know first hand the hard work that the staff and dev team volunteered to do in order to produce this new gameplay for the players benefit, and for you to go ahead with your childish and closed minded attitude and say 'you guys are trying to ruin the server' after they tried to improve your personal experience is completely inappropriate and unacceptable in my book.
-If you read this with skepticism, he basically is saying his last statement but he is blowing it up to extreme proportions that don't even represent who @Purple is or what he did. "For you to go ahead with your childish and closed minded attitude and say "you guys are trying to ruin the server" .... is completely unacceptable". Dude, purple is 15 years old. Do you expect a server with an age group of 13+ to have a bunch of intellects that think with an open mind? The brain isn't fully developed until 26. When you put hard work into a free-to-join, unwhitelisted garry's mod server, you aren't going to get perfection with the community. "Sure thats why we ban off the toxic ones"..... I get it, ban off the toxic ones. But what he said is toxic in the eyes of another close minded person. Anyone with a truly open mind would agree that saying ""!help are you guys trying to ruin the server like what am I supposed to do?"" isn't toxic and should have been let go and maybe sent off with a warning. But no, @Scofield decided "THIS IS ABSOLUTELY HORRENDOUS", and gave him a week ban. Why is this behavior tolerated within the staff team? I can guarantee you that @Purple's feelings were hurt because of this WAY MORE than any of the hard-working staff members/dev team that went into the map change. He said he was sorry and didn't mean harm, but Scofield with his power-hungry attitude wanted this man punished as a form of authoritative control. I'll say it again, absolutely NO HARM was done from this comment. It's not like he went around in OOC saying it too, in character, and then proceeded to break rules because of it! A week ban wasn't necessary. Along with this, the way he handled the appeal was very unprofessional. He didn't take it on in a neutral manner what-so-ever. Why is it that hard for you to give another person a chance?
The reason why I put NITRP as one of your ban reasons is due to the fact that you used the !help command to slander and insult members of the community, and not to ask RP related questions like it is designed for. For the reasons displayed above, this ban appeal is going to be DENIED. Additionaly, if you are not happy with my handling of the situation, you may make a staff report on me here."
-Again, this is such an excessive explanation of what really happened. More realistically, purple used the !help command to make a slightly disrespectful comment towards a decision made by the server. The definition of slander is "a false verbal statement that damages one's reputation". So, he misused the word slander there to exaggerate his point. I am not happy with the way he handled this situation, and the staff report is being made. And that reasoning itself is COMPLETELY UNRELATED to "No intent to role-play". It was just another reason he added so he could justify his excessive ban time.
Time of Occurrence:Tuesday, 4/7/20
Evidence to support your claim:
Jordon Milestone's Ban Appeal
Ban Appeal Format ______________________________________________________________ Steam Name: Purple Your SteamID32(You can obtain this from steamid.io): steamID STEAM_0:1:181086855 | steamID3 [U:1:362173711] | steamID64 76561198322439439 Your Character Name: Jordon Milestone Ban Length: 1...
monolithservers.com
None, I'm sure he didn't even ask other staff members if his decision was fair before responding. He probably thought what he wrote was perfect. More reasons he's not fit to be a staff member.
Read, understood and followed staff report rules?:
Yes
Last edited:
That's not exactly what he said.