xstewart FTVL

[Galaxar]

Your Steam Name: Galaxar
Your Steam ID: STEAM_0:0:156699963
Your Character Name (If Applicable): Larry Johnson

Admin being reported @xstewart

Reason for Report: Me, Jev Johanson and Tomasz Cooper were robbing the L2 bank with one hostage, we putted the hostage to the vault and waited for the cops, cops arrived to the front and for some reason(Even when we putted /ad We have hostage) one started imidiaetly shooting me, so I yelled in chat again that we have hostage and I yelled once more in the chat that one cop can go in to check there is one and negotiate with us. After that I rushed to the vault because I got shot by that one cop and didn't wanted to risk getting another shot. After that, me, Jev and Tomasz aimed at the hostage as xstewart comes in the bank aiming his M4 towards us, and proceeds to shoot us even when all of us were aiming at the hostage.

Time of Occurrence: 4/10/2021 7:48:43 AM

Evidence to support your claim: @Thanewolfe , https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/818125149151821854/830485575383253042/LAMO.png < This is screenshot of us aiming at hostage and me getting demage from xstewart,

4/10/2021 @ 7:48:43 AM Larry Johnson (Galaxar) (STEAM_0:0:156699963) (654) entered state CRITICAL Damage
4/10/2021 @ 7:48:43 AM Larry Johnson (Galaxar) (STEAM_0:0:156699963) (654) was killed by: Stewart James (xstewart) (STEAM_0:1:215903220) (169) with a cw_vector
Deaths 4/10/2021 @ 7:48:43 AM Larry Johnson (Galaxar) (STEAM_0:0:156699963) (654) was damaged by: Stewart James (xstewart) (STEAM_0:1:215903220) (169) for 8 damage with a
cw_vector (Chest)
Damage 4/10/2021 @ 7:48:42 AM Larry Johnson (Galaxar) (STEAM_0:0:156699963) (654) was damaged by: Stewart James (xstewart) (STEAM_0:1:215903220) (169) for 15 damage with a cw_vector (Head) Damage 4/10/2021 @ 7:48:42 AM Larry Johnson (Galaxar) (STEAM_0:0:156699963) (654) was damaged by: Stewart James (xstewart) (STEAM_0:1:215903220) (169) for 8 damage with a cw_vector (Stomach)
Damage 4/10/2021 @ 7:48:42 AM Larry Johnson (Galaxar) (STEAM_0:0:156699963) (654) was damaged by: Stewart James (xstewart) (STEAM_0:1:215903220) (169) for 13 damage with a cw_vector (Right Arm)
Damage 4/10/2021 @ 7:48:42 AM Larry Johnson (Galaxar) (STEAM_0:0:156699963) (654) was damaged by: Stewart James (xstewart) (STEAM_0:1:215903220) (169) for 15 damage with a cw_vector (Head)
Damage 4/10/2021 @ 7:48:42 AM Larry Johnson (Galaxar) (STEAM_0:0:156699963) (654) was damaged by: Stewart James (xstewart) (STEAM_0:1:215903220) (169) for 13 damage with a cw_vector (Left Arm)
Damage 4/10/2021 @ 7:47:50 AM Larry Johnson (Galaxar) (STEAM_0:0:156699963) (654) ran chat command: "/yell" - "Dont worry will not trying anything"
Communication 4/10/2021 @ 7:47:42 AM Larry Johnson (Galaxar) (STEAM_0:0:156699963) (654) ran chat command: "/yell" - "YOU WANT HIM DEAD OR WHAT?" Communication
THESE ARE LOGS SENT TO ME BY Thanewolfe as a part of evidience.

Additional members involved/witnessing: No-one
Read, understood and followed staff report rules? Yes

 

[StewartJames]

Hi, pretty simple one here.

1) I arrive on scene and request you to *begin negotiations.*
2) To do this, I ask for you to show us the hostage.
3) You tell me to come in the back to see him.
4) I say he has to come out front, as is procedure so you don't take me hostage. You refuse.
5) I say either I see the hostage or we come and get him.
6) I don't see him, we come and get him.
7) Note, the hostage survives.
8) Mid breach, we come across a hostage. Too late for that now.
9) We shoot to stop.
10) The scene is called code 4, with the PD having fulfilled their role in the rules of being "required to begin negotiations" before using our right to "call them off at any time"

Please note, no video evidence supplied in this report.

Ta.

 

[Melody]

Hello,

Thank you for your report. After review of the screenshot and logs provided, and both of your stories, there is insufficient evidence to show a rule break by @StewartJames.

From Stewart's side of the story he made a reasonable request to see the hostage at the front instead of going into an unknown situation to protect himself. This request is not upheld, and after negotiations fail, attempts to retrieve the hostage and deal with the threat of the robbers are made. As per rule 5.2.8;

In a hostage situation, you are obligated to value the life of the hostage and begin negotiations. A superior Law Enforcement Officer/Lead Negotiator may, however, call off negotiations at any time if they are not being successful. This includes, but it is not limited to the hostage takers not complying with negotiation terms, constantly threatening law enforcement or refusing to negotiate.

Without further evidence, it seems he followed all rules by attempting a negotiation and subsequently calling it off. Staff report denied.

-Melody